My favorites:
- H.P. Lovecraft – Short Stories
Great (5/5):
- David Wong – John Dies at the End
- Joe R. Lansdale – Edge of Dark Water
- Richard Matheson – I am Legend
Good (4/5):
- Clive Barker – The Great and Secret Show
- Clive Barker – The Hellbound Heart
- Dan Simmons – Song of Kali
- David Wong – This Book is Full of Spiders
- Donald Ray Pollock – Devil All The Time
- Iain Banks – The Wasp Factory
- Richard Preston – The Hot Zone
- Robert Jackson Bennett – American Elsewhere
- Robert McCammon – Swan Song
- Shirley Jackson – We Have Always Lived in the Castle
- Stephen King – It
- Stephen King – Needful Things
Fine (3/5):
- Ania Ahlborn – Seed
- Bram Stoker – Dracula
- Clive Barker – The Weaveworld
- Dan Simmons – Summer of Night
- H.P. Lovecraft – At the Mountains of Madness
- Ira Levin – Rosemary’s Baby
- Jack Ketchum – Off Season
- Jeff Strand – Pressure
- Joe Hill – Horns
- Joe Hill – In the Tall Grass
- John Ajvide Lindqvist – Handling the Undead
- John Saul – Shadows
- Grady Hendrix – Horrorstor
- Paul Tremblay – A Head Full of Ghosts
- Stephen King – Cujo
- Stephen King – Doctor Sleep
- Stephen King – Pet Sematary
- Stephen King – The Duma Key
- Stephen King – The Shining
- Susan Hill – The Woman in Black
- Robert McCammon – Boy’s Life
Meh (2/5):
- Brian Keene – Darkness at the Edge of Town
- Clive Barker – Cabal
- Clive Barker – The Thief of Always
- Clive Barker – Everville
- Dan Wells – I Am Not a Serial Killer
- Dan Wells – Mr. Monster
- David Morrel – Creepers
- Dean Koontz – Hideaway
- Edgar Alan Poe – Short Stories
- F. Paul Wilson – The Keep
- H.P. Lovecraft – The Case of Charles Dexter Ward
- Jeff VanderMeer – Southern Reach
- Jennifer McMahon – The Winter People
- Joe Hill – Heart-Shaped Box
- Joe Hill – NOS4A
- Joe Mckinney – Dead City
- Joe Mckinney – Apocalypse of the Dead
- John Saul – Black Creek Crossing
- John Saul – Black Lightning
- John Saul – Darkness
- John Saul – The Manhattan Hunt Club
- John Saul – The Right Hand of Evil
- Neil Gaiman – The Ocean at the End of the Lane
- Owl Goingback – Darker Than Night
- Peter Straub – Lost Boy, Lost Girl
- Peter Straub – In the Night Room
- Sarah Pinborough – A Necessary End
Bad (1/5):
- Clive Barker – The Damnation Game
- Deant Koontz – Midnight
- John Soul – The Presence
- Peter Straub – Shadowland
- Richard Matheson – Hell House
Crap (0/5):