Game of Thrones was one show that I actually wasn’t worried about deviating from the original material because I figured that to achieve the heights it did, everyone involved must have known what they were doing as it wasn’t like George R. R. Martin was writing every scene, but… It appears I couldn’t have been more wrong–the way they dropped the ball with the final season is legendary.
The tense atmosphere is gone, everyone has plot armor, the characters are making dumb decisions that feel nothing like them, the battle strategy is abysmal and all battles are won through magic, and most of the events feel rushed and not set up properly. It simply doesn’t feel like Game of Thrones anymore. It’s still better than what you normally see on TV, but this is Game of Thrones we’re talking about, not goddamn Hercules: The Legendary Journey.
While I thought I didn’t need to pick up the books while I was around season four, I started having doubts through season five and six, until I finally realized I simply had to read them to get a proper conclusion to the story around season seven. At this point, I really can’t help but treat the last two seasons as fan fiction that I give no more credit than alternative fan endings on youtube, which also happen to be infinitely better.
The underwhelming last season doesn’t change all the amazing things that came prior to it, and the first four seasons of Game of Thrones (and arguably five and six too) still remain my favorite TV series. I’ll be looking forward to see how the story actually concludes if George R. R. Martin finishes the damn books.
Seasons based on books:
Original material:
Positive:
|
Negative:
|
Awesome cinematography
|
Action scenes use too many jumpcuts in the earlier seasons
|
Fascinating, gritty medieval fantasy setting
|
The integrity of the plot falls apart in the original seasons |
Immersing, dark atmosphere
|
Characters act out of character and are dumbed down in the later seasons |
Interesting, likable, profound characters
|
Abysmal battle tactics in the final season |
Enthralling plot full of surprising twists
|
Poorly written ending |
Fantastic pacing with something interesting happening every minute
|
|
Solid, well thought-out story fueled by medieval politics
|